“EDMUND JUSTICE”
Vol
5, July 2005
“WORKING IT OUT - NEW
WORKPLACE PROPOSALS”
“The economy
must serve people, not the other way around. All workers have a right
to productive work, to decent and fair wages, and to safe working
conditions. They also have a fundamental right to organize and join
unions. People have a right to economic initiative and private
property, but these rights have limits.”
(Principle no 6 - Catholic Social
Teaching)
Some of the federal government's proposed Workplace Changes:
 |
creating federal body to set wages – FAIR PAY COMMISSION |
 |
removing state industrial relations systems to settle
industrial disputes |
 |
changing enterprise bargaining |
 |
excluding businesses with fewer than 100 employees from
unfair dismissal laws |
 |
6 month probation for new employees |
Responses from Catholic Church
The Australian Catholic Commission for Employment Relations
is worried that up to 95% of businesses could become exempt from unfair
dismissals.
 |
Cardinal Pell is concerned that “minimum wages could be
pushed lower in real terms”. “The disparity between rich and poor is
of some concern, but it is different if the minimum wage is still rising.”
|
 |
Bishop Pat Power of Canberra raises questions about whether
workers would have certainty that they “cannot be dismissed arbitrarily
and without due process” |
 |
Bishop Manning defends the church’s teaching of labour over
capital. “Our economic system should serve the human person, rather
than treating people as disposable factors of production.” |
 |
Bishop Manning also says “the test of workplace relations
is whether or not ordinary workers have safe and healthy work conditions,
wages sufficient to support their families.” |
A group of 17 leading academic
researchers in the area of labour market & industrial relations examined the
proposals and gave this report:
1.
 |
employee rights could be undermined |
 |
employees could have less freedom of
choice |
 |
right to collective bargaining
threatened |
2.
 |
labour laws corporatised |
 |
high court to determine whether govt
has power to enact national industrial law (section 53 – Australian
constitution) |
 |
possible conflict of interest if
labour laws come under corporation law |
3.
 |
safety net compromised |
 |
award system diminished |
 |
no viable alternative for establishing
minimum standards |
4.
 |
wage inequality increased |
 |
growing income inequality |
 |
less protection for low-paid workers |
5.
 |
job security weakened |
 |
high levels of casual work |
 |
casual workers - less protection of
conditions |
6.
 |
unfair dismissal |
 |
exemption for companies no guarantee
of new jobs |
For further information on this report
go to
http://www.econ.usyd.edu.au/content.php?pageid=14896
Web links
Australian Catholic Commission for
employment Relations
http://www.accer.asn.au/
Dept of Employment & Workplace relations
http://www.workplace.gov.au/
“Australia has a long
and proud tradition of settling industrial disputes and promoting
cooperation by its almost unique system of arbitration.”
(Open
letter by Pope John Paul 11 to workers, 1986)
Past Volumes
Vol 1, February 2005
3RD WORLD POVERTY –
The Other Tsunami
Vol 2, March 2005
STILL COOKING WITH GAS IN EAST TIMOR
Vol 3, April 2005
INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS – SOME HARD TRUTHS
Vol 4, June 2005
REFUGEES - I WAS A STRANGER AND YOU MADE ME
WELCOME
|